- LittleLaw
- Posts
- š® Why PlayStation just beat a Ā£2 billion lawsuit (a year after Apple lost the same argument)
š® Why PlayStation just beat a Ā£2 billion lawsuit (a year after Apple lost the same argument)

Together with
If you take just one thing from this email...
Sony just beat a claim worth almost £2 billion, brought for 12.2 million UK PlayStation users who said it overcharged them for digital games.
The gamers had to show Sony was ādominantā (so powerful in its market that it can ignore rivals). If you draw the market narrowly ā for example, PlayStation downloads only ā Sony is dominant. But if you draw it widely ā as consoles and games together ā it isnāt.
The tribunal went with the wide market, but a year earlier, it went with the narrow one for Appleās App Store and ruled against Apple.

TOGETHER WITH BARBRI* š¤
How much could you save on your SQE preparation this Black Friday?
Here's your chance to plan ahead and save on your route to qualification.
BARBRI's Black Friday, Bright Future sale launched this Monday, with discounts on courses starting in 2027, plus revision tools for the January exams.
You can save:
š· Ā£450 off SQE1 and SQE2 Prep
š Ā£600 off SQE Complete (SQE1 + SQE2) when you add SQE1 Mocks to your basket
š Discounts on SQE1 and SQE2 revision tools for the January 2027 exams
šŗšø $1,000 off Extended US Bar Prep
Whether you're planning the start of your SQE journey or preparing for your upcoming SQE1 exams, it's worth seeing what's on offer.
The sale has just gone live now and only runs until 30 November, so don't miss your chance to save on your SQE preparation.
*This is sponsored content

FEATURED REPORT š°
š® Why PlayStation just beat a Ā£2 billion lawsuit (a year after Apple lost the same argument)

Whatās going on here?
Yesterday, Sony (the maker of PlayStation) beat a lawsuit worth almost Ā£2 billion. It was brought on behalf of about 12.2 million UK PlayStation users who claimed it had overcharged them for digital games. The Competition Appeal Tribunal (the UKās specialist court for competition cases) threw the whole claim out.
Last year, the same tribunal ruled against Apple, saying it broke competition law by taking a cut of up to 30% on its App Store. Sony takes about the same cut on its PlayStation Store, but it won.
What did the gamers say Sony did wrong?
If you own a PlayStation and want to download a game, there is one online shop you can use ā the PlayStation Store (which is, of course, run by Sony). No other company is allowed to run a store on the console. Sony sets the prices in that shop. It keeps the full price on its own games and about 30% on games from other publishers.
The claim said this arrangement cost gamers money. With no rival shop to compete on price, Sony could charge more. If Sony had let other stores in to compete, the claim argued, digital games would have been about 20% cheaper.
š¤ Who actually sued?
A consumer campaigner called Alex Neill brought the case on behalf of everyone affected. It was an āopt-outā class action, where every UK user who fits the description is included automatically unless they ask to leave. If you bought a digital PlayStation game or add-on in the UK between August 2016 and February 2026, that probably included you.
Section 18 of the Competition Act 1998 bans companies from āabusing a dominant positionā (thatās what Sony was accused of). A company is dominant when itās so powerful in a market that it can act without worrying much about rivals or customers. Being dominant is allowed, but using that power unfairly is not. Shutting out rivals and overcharging customers are the two main ways of doing that, and the claim accused Sony of both.
Before a company can abuse a dominant position, it has to have a dominant position to start with. So the first question was whether Sony was dominant in the market at all.
How do you decide what āthe marketā is?
A company can only be dominant in a particular market. So before anyone can say whether Sony had too much power, someone has to decide what that āmarketā is.
The answer to that depends on where you draw the line. If you draw the market narrowly, a company looks huge. Draw it widely and the same company looks like one player among several.
Competition lawyers decide where the line goes by asking what alternatives customers could switch to.
Letās say one company sold every banana in the UK and put its prices up by 5% to 10%. As a result, imagine that many shoppers switched to apples instead. So the banana company made less money than before. That shows that apples are in the same market as bananas. If most shoppers kept buying bananas anyway, bananas are a market of their own. This is called the SSNIP test, short for a āsmall but significant non-transitory increase in priceā.
In this case, each side drew the line in a different place:
š The narrow market (the gamersā argument): They claimed the market was digital PlayStation games and add-ons only. Once you own a PlayStation, youāre locked in. You canāt play Xbox games on it, and the PlayStation Store is the only place to download from. Inside this market Sony has 100% of sales, so it looks clearly dominant.

š The wide market (Sonyās argument): It argued the market was entire gaming systems, meaning the console plus the games you buy for it. People choose between PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo, and the cost of games is part of that choice. If Sony pushes its game prices too high, people buy a different console next time. Inside this market Sony has two big rivals, so it argued it wasnāt dominant.

Lawyers call the narrow version an āaftermarketā and the wide version a āsystems marketā.
Which one is right comes down largely to this question: when you buy a console, do you think about what the games will cost?
ā If yes: Game prices are part of how people choose a console. So if Sony charges too much for games, it loses console buyers to Xbox and Nintendo. That threat keeps its game prices in check. Therefore the market is the wide one, Sony isnāt dominant and the claim fails.
ā If no: People choose a console first and only meet the game prices later. By then theyāre locked in, so rival consoles do nothing to hold Sonyās game prices down. Therefore the market is the narrow one, Sony is dominant and the claim moves on to whether it abused that power.
Why did the tribunal choose the wide market?
The tribunalās answer was yes. It found that people do think about game prices when they choose a console. Three factors helped it reach this decision:
š Sonyās own research: Sonyās surveys showed that console shoppers look for game prices when they are choosing. One internal report, called āProject Leprechaunā, worked out what a Ā£10 rise in game prices would do to console sales. It predicted Sony could sell fewer PlayStations if it raised game prices and Xbox didnāt.
šæ Discs: During the years the claim covered, you could still buy PlayStation games on physical disc from other shops. The tribunal found that if digital prices rose by 5% to 10%, enough players would go back to discs to matter. Thatās the banana test from earlier, applied to games.
š® Other consoles: Some players own more than one console, and some games work across consoles, purchases included. Both make it easier to spend your money somewhere other than PlayStation.
So the tribunal went with the wide market. There, Sony has to compete with Xbox and Nintendo, which means it isnāt dominant. With no dominant position to abuse, the claim failed at the first step.
So why did Apple lose a similar case last year?
In October 2025, the same tribunal ruled on a claim against Apple that looked a lot like the one against Sony. If you own an iPhone or iPad, the App Store is the only place to get apps, and Apple takes a cut of up to 30% on paid apps and in-app purchases. Another opt-out class action, this time for about 36 million UK users, said that 30% cut was too high and that users ended up paying for it.
Apple defended itself the same way Sony later did. It said the market was a wide one, covering phones and apps together, with iPhone up against Android.
So the tribunal asked the same question. When you buy a phone, do you think about what the apps will cost?
This time the answer was no. People choose a phone for lots of reasons, but app prices are rarely one of them. And almost nobody was going to switch to Android over Appleās cut.
That sent Apple down the āif noā path. The market was the narrow one (apps on Apple devices), where Apple had 100% control. It was dominant, and the tribunal went on to find it had abused that position. The usersā lawyers estimated the compensation that Apple should pay at about Ā£1.5 billion. Apple is currently challenging the ruling in the Court of Appeal.
Two other differences helped reach that outcome for Apple:
šæ PlayStation owners could buy discs. iPhone owners had nowhere else to get apps.
š° The App Store made about 75p of profit on every Ā£1 it brought in. Sony sells its consoles at little or no profit and earns the money back on games, so the tribunal looked at the console and the games together.
It was the same tribunal applying the same legal test, on similar facts. What differed was how people actually shop (and that decided how the āmarketā was defined). Thatās why working out the market is often the whole fight in a competition case.
What happens now?
The two sides go back to the tribunal in the week of 14 December to deal with legal costs and any request to appeal. Alex Neill has said she is considering one.
In case you were wondering, if you were one of the 12.2 million users, thereās no compensation to claim under this ruling, no bill to pay and nothing you need to do.
But Sony has said new PlayStation games will stop coming out on disc from January 2028. The tribunal only looked at the years the claim covered, when discs were still a way round. If you take the discs away, the same question about the market could get a different answer.
Which law firms were involved?
Linklaters acted for Sony, and Milberg London acted for Alex Neill and the PlayStation users. The claim was paid for by Woodsford, a litigation funder.
How can you use this in your applications?
1ļøā£ If youāre interested in competition law, this is a good story to talk about
To show your interest in competition law, you should have a recent story you can talk about on an application form or in an interview. This is a good one to use. Hereās how to tell it.
ā Know what happened (in one sentence). Sony beat a claim worth almost Ā£2 billion, brought for 12.2 million UK PlayStation users who said it overcharged them for digital games.
ā Say what surprised you. A year earlier, the same tribunal ruled against Apple in a very similar case. Both companies run the only store on their device, and both take about 30%.
ā Explain why the results were different. The rule against abusing market power only applies to a company that is dominant in its market. People think about game prices when they choose a console, so Sony has to compete with Xbox and Nintendo. People rarely think about app prices when they choose a phone, so the App Store was treated as a market of its own.
ā Say why a law firm would care. Lots of businesses work the same way. A printer maker sells you the printer and then the ink. It might ask a law firm whether it can stop customers using cheaper ink from rivals. Law firms advise businesses like these on how competition law applies to them.
ā Say why it interests you. A lot of applicants say they like competition law because itās a mix of law and economics. That is too general to help an interviewer. This story gives you something specific to say. The law was the same in both cases, and the result depended on evidence about how customers behave.
š¬ What you could say
āI was interested in Sony beating a Ā£2 billion claim over PlayStation Store prices. A year earlier, the same tribunal ruled against Apple over a similar 30% cut on its App Store. The difference was the market. Gamers think about game prices when they choose a console, so Sony competes with Xbox and Nintendo. Phone buyers rarely think about app prices. I found it interesting that the same law gave two different results because customers behave differently.ā
2ļøā£ In a case study, ask what the āmarketā is before you say a company is too big
Some case studies ask you to advise a client that wants to buy a rival company. You are expected to notice that competition law could be a problem. Many candidates write that both companies are large, so the deal might be blocked, and say nothing more.
ā Ask what the market is. Imagine your client is a coffee chain buying another coffee chain. If the market is coffee shops, the two together might be the biggest seller by far. If the market also includes supermarkets, bakeries and petrol stations that sell coffee, they are much smaller.
ā Use the banana test from this article. Imagine every coffee shop in the area put its prices up by 5% to 10%. If enough customers would switch to supermarkets, bakeries or petrol stations instead, those sellers are part of the market too. If thatās the case, you could argue the two chains are only a small part of a much bigger market, so the deal still leaves customers with plenty of choice.
ā Say what you would need to see. Sonyās own customer research helped it win. In a case study, say you would ask where the clientās customers would go if their usual branch closed. If most would go to the chain your client wants to buy, thatās bad news for the deal. It shows the two chains are each otherās closest rival, so the regulator is more likely to block it or ask your client to sell some shops. If customers would spread out across lots of other sellers, that helps your client.
You canāt tell whether a company is too powerful until you know what market it is in. Saying that in a case study shows you understand how competition lawyers approach the problem.

How did you find today's newsletter? |

